`gh stack checkout` reports "Local stack matches remote" without comparing local branch refs

[xn]

Summary

gh stack checkout reports ✓ Local stack matches remote when a local branch has diverged from its remote counterpart. It appears to compare its recorded state against the remote, and never against the actual local branch refs — so a local branch that has moved is invisible to the check.

$ git rev-parse --short=10 stack-b-two            # local
df863cea57
$ git rev-parse --short=10 origin/stack-b-two     # remote, one commit ahead
41fd74d3ae

$ gh stack checkout 6
✓ Local stack matches remote — switching to branch (stack #6)
ℹ Already on stack-b-two

$ gh stack view --short                           # no warning, no ⚠ Needs rebase
Stack #6
» stack-b-two ○ #5 (current)
├ stack-b-one ○ #4
└ main

The extension's own state file held the correct value the whole time:

$ jq -r '.stacks[].branches[] | select(.branch=="stack-b-two") | .head' .git/gh-stack
41fd74d3ae...        # matches the remote; the local ref is what diverged

So this is not stale metadata. Recorded state and remote agreed, the local ref disagreed with both, and nothing compared against it.

Why this matters

This is the reassurance a user sees immediately before #380 destroys their work. In that state gh stack push rewinds the remote branch and the commits become unreachable — and if the branch loses its only commit, GitHub auto-closes the PR with no files. The sequence is:

gh stack checkout <n>      -> "✓ Local stack matches remote"
gh stack push              -> "✓ Pushed N branches"   (remote commits gone, PR closed)

Fixing #380 addresses the destruction. Fixing this addresses the false confidence that leads someone to run the command in the first place.

How a local branch gets behind

Anything not mediated by the extension. A plain git fetch after a colleague pushes; CI committing to the PR head branch (the trigger in #380); or building a change in a git worktree and pushing it with git push origin <scratch-ref>:<pr-branch>, which moves the remote and leaves the local branch untouched.

Reproduction

Against a stack whose branches are in sync:

git switch <top-branch>
git reset --hard HEAD~1          # simulate the local branch falling behind
gh stack checkout <stack-number> # -> "✓ Local stack matches remote"
gh stack view --short            # -> no warning

Public repo with two stacks set up for this: https://github.com/xn/gh-stack-repro

Expected

Compare recorded/remote heads against the actual local branch refs. On divergence, say so and name the fix (git branch -f <b> origin/<b>), rather than reporting a match.

A gh stack status / gh stack doctor surfacing per-branch local-vs-remote drift would cover the general case, since plain git will always be able to desync the extension's state.

Environment

• gh 2.97.0
• gh-stack v0.1.0
• git 2.50.1
• macOS 26.4.1, darwin/arm64

Related

• gh stack push silently discards commits that exist only on the remote (fetch-then-lease defeats --force-with-lease) #380 — the data loss this false reassurance leads into.
• Stacking should handle rebases performed outside of gh stack #193 — handling rebases performed outside gh stack; same general gap (external git operations invisible to the extension).